Despite being twins, Bryson and Wayne have two different fathers. While Bryson's dad still lives in St. Louis, Wayne's dad has moved all the way across the state. But soon, a big change is coming for the twins' entire family.

Bryson's plans to hang out with his dad are thwarted when he shows up at Dad's house and walks in on a naked stranger. Bryson's dad tells him he can spend the night, but will Bryson get any sleep with all of the action happening in the next room?

Hunter returns to St. Louis, moving in with his cousin Leroy. Their two sons are there to help with the move – but the boys don't know their fathers' biggest secret. Once alone, the cousins are free to reminisce about what happened all those years ago.

Leroy has always tried to maintain a close relationship with Wayne, even though he is not his biological father. But when Wayne stumbles upon some of Leroy's sexy photos, they quickly end up getting much closer than they anticipated.

Wayne decides to come out to his brother, but regrets that he can't tell him the full truth about the guy he hooked up with. That evening, the twins' dads host the whole family for dinner, and Wayne gets a mind-blowing surprise.

After Wayne comes out, Bryson is determined not to allow the dynamic between them to change. But what happens when Bryson comes back home early one night to stumble upon his twin brother's shocking secret?