College freshman Trevor is shocked to come home for Thanksgiving and find out that his parents now have a boyfriend. Trevor's relationship with his dads' new partner is off to a rocky start… but it soon takes a very interesting turn.

Gordon is stunned to find out his son has seen his boyfriend in the nude. What follows is an awkward conversation between father and son… which leads to an unexpected reaction from an aroused Gordon.

Spencer is happy to learn that his son and his boyfriend are building a close relationship. As Christmas approaches, Rik pushes Spence to become more sexually adventurous – in the presence of the rest of the family.

With his boyfriends' son home for the holidays, Rik tries to be on his best behavior, but a mix-up leads to some embarrassing exposure. Later, Rik overhears Trevor making a shocking confession.

During the holidays, Trevor goes to visit his friend's house when he realizes he grabbed his dad's phone by mistake. Although he's loath to invade his parents' privacy, Trevor simply can't help but go through some intimate messages…

Caught red-handed by his best friend's dad, Trevor freaks out and doesn't know what to do. Thankfully, Graham is understanding and the two of them agree to keep the incident a secret. And since they're already keeping secrets…

Assuming that his son is out, Gordon bursts into Trevor's room and is treated to a surprising sight. Later, Rik learns the meaning of the term "jizz rag" and he engages Gordon in some forbidden – yet arousing – action.

In a drunk outburst of honesty, Trevor shares secrets about his sexuality with one of his dads. The following day, Gordon and Trevor go to New York City together, where they visit a gym owned by a stud named Owen…