MASON:

    Things with Malik as my boyfriend were going better than I could've even hoped for. We spent about half our time having deeply personal conversations – while the other half, we fucked like only two horny teenage boys could!

    Our sexual encounters were no secret to my brothers. After hearing them talk about their sexploits with girls for so many years – at times getting into WAY TOO MUCH graphic detail – I was now eager to show off to Wyatt and Finn, and let them see the quality dick I was getting. And oh boy, we're talking grade-A quality! Even though he was only a year older than me, Malik sure knew what he was doing. He could fuck me for over an hour without cumming; other times, he'd fuck me in short intervals and cum inside me four or five times within an hour. 

    On the Friday before Memorial Day, I gave Malik such a good blowjob that once he got his dick inside my ass, he only lasted about fifteen minutes. After breeding my guts, he and I cuddled and chilled out on the couch in the basement. My brothers had been with us earlier, watching me blow my boyfriend for a while, but they'd since disappeared, leaving Malik and me alone.

    "Fuck, I could really go for a smoke right about now. You got any?" Malik asked me.

    "No," I shook my head. I smoked weed if someone offered it to me, but I never bought my own.

    "Shit. How bout your brothers?" my boyfriend asked next.

    "I don't think they have any either."

    "Okay. I think I can get some from my dad, but he's still at the diner."

    "First of all, I love that you get your weed from your dad," I laughed. "And driving to the diner and back will take less than half an hour, right?"

    "If there's no traffic. Plus, I'm in the mood for something sweet after that pizza… and that ass," he added, smacking my bare behind.

    "It's settled then. Go to the diner and I'll see you here in a bit," I said.

    "Oh, you not coming with me?"

    "Nah, I wanna check on my brothers," I said.

    "Alright. I'll see you in a bit," he said with a goodbye kiss before putting his clothes on and leaving the house.

    Still naked, I went up the stairs to see what Wyatt and Finn were up to. Feeling my boyfriend's cum churning inside my ass got my cock hard all over again, and I only got harder when I heard loud voices coming out of Wyatt's room.

    "Yeah. Go harder. Fuck my ass!"

    "Broooo. You sure this your first time?"

    "Less joking, more poking. C'mon. FUUUUUUCK, that's the spot. Right there. Right fucking there! Go at it! Keep going! Fuck."

    The fact that Finn was getting fucked came as no big surprise. Since coming out as bi, he was curious to explore and experiment, and try out everything man-on-man sex could offer. However, I was surprised by Wyatt's participation in all this. True, he'd already had his dick sucked by Finn before, but this was a much bigger step for two people to take than just a blowjob – especially when those two people were brothers!

    "Wow!! You're really going for it all the way!" I announced my way into Wyatt's room.

    If they were surprised to see me here, my brothers didn't show it. Wyatt just kept on fucking without missing a beat. His only comment was about the state of my dick.

    "You ain't cum yet?" Wyatt asked, pointing out my throbbing erection.

    "Not yet. Mind if I join in?" I said, taking a step toward the bed. I wasn't sure what would happen next, but Wyatt directed the situation. He took Finn by the armpits, lifting him up and off the bed. Then, Wyatt rotated Finn so he was facing me, his mouth agape and panting.

    I looked Wyatt in the eyes, and he just smirked at me – a gesture that turned me on even more! I took the final few steps toward them until I felt Finn's lips touching my cockhead. Finn opened his mouth even wider, inviting me in it. I didn't move a muscle, and I didn't need to. By fucking Finn, Wyatt was making his whole body oscillate, moving back and forth between our brotherly cocks.

    "Fuck, he's taking it from both sides," Wyatt said, impressed by our sibling's stating. "You enjoying this, Finn?"

    "Mhmmmm," Finn nodded as much as he could with my hard meat filling his mouth. His throat felt warm and welcoming.

    "How's his ass?" I asked Wyatt.

    "Tight, but just right," he winked at me. "He's sooo good. Especially for a first-timer."

    "How you liking your first time, then?" I asked, taking my cock out of Finn's mouth so he could answer. Honestly, my question was unnecessary: I could tell by my brother's body language how much he was enjoying this. Yet I wanted to hear him say the words. I wanted him to admit he liked getting fucked by our straight brother.

    "Ahhhhh! Mmm. AH! It's amazing. Fucking phenomenal," Finn panted, barely able to speak, saliva and precum dripping down his chin. "Ahhhh, fuck me Wyatt. Fuck, his dick is so good! So fucking good!"

    Finn's eyes rolled to the back of his head, and I shoved my cock down his throat once again. He certainly made our brother's tool sound good, making me curious about it. I reached forward as much as I could, placing my hand on Finn's ass and trying to touch his asshole, right where Wyatt's cock was drilling it.

    "Fuck, that's hot!" I said as I felt my brother's dick fuck my other brother's ass. My fingertips were touching Wyatt's shaft as it thrusted back and forth, coming out of Finn's ass all sticky with lube, precum, and sweat. "You gon bust inside him?" I found myself asking Wyatt.

    "Fuck. You want me to?" Wyatt asked Finn, thrusting even harder as if turned on by the idea.

    "Fuck yeah," Finn replied, holding my cock to his face. "I want you both to cum inside me."

    "Yeah? You wanna swallow my load?" I smoked down at my brother.

    "No," he replied, to my surprise. "I want you to cum up my ass as well."

    "Fuckin' hell," Wyatt swore, thrusting faster back and forth inside Finn. While Finn continued to suck my cock, Wyatt made eye contact with me, as if to check whether I was up for Finn's challenge.

    "You go first," I told Wyatt, encouraging him to breed our brother's hole with his straight man's sperm. While looking me dead in the eyes, Wyatt's face contorted and he began busting his nut inside Finn, giving his ass its first ever breeding. 

    "Fuuuuuuck," Wyatt and I moaned simultaneously. In a hurry, I had to pull my dick out of Finn's mouth, as I was in danger of cumming sooner than I wanted to. My cock continued to throb in my brother's face as I watched him get loaded up by Wyatt. Then, I quickly got behind Finn and watched as Wyatt pulled out of him.

    "Fuck," I said. Unable to resist the temptation, I dropped down to my knees and took Wyatt's tool in my mouth, quickly sucking off the sperm that was on there, as well as the sweat that had come from Finn's ass. In that moment, I found myself uncontrollably hungry for cum – my brother's suck. After sucking all of it off his cock, I turned to Finn's ass, burying my tongue in his hole and digging around, lapping up Wyatt's seed. Once Finn realized what I was trying to do, he pushed out and let our brother's cum go inside my mouth and down my throat.

    "Fuck, are you eating my load out of there?" Wyatt asked, stroking his still-hard cock right next to me. 

    "Mhm," I nodded while swallowing Wyatt's babies. Then, I got up and rewarded Finn by shoving my dick up his ass and adding another load to it, to replace the one I'd just scarfed down.

    "AHHHH!!!" Finn and I shouted. As I bred my brother's ass, he simultaneously blew his own load all over Wyatt's bed. It was my first time fucking someone's ass, and as such it was also the most intense orgasm of my life. Wad after wad of jizz shot out of me, filling Finn's hole to the brim until my cum began to spill out.

    "Fuuuuck. Are your loads always this big?" Wyatt commented from the side. Even though he couldn't see my cumshot, he could tell just how much spunk had shot out of me, since I was cumming for over two minutes.

    "Hell no. That's never happened before," I replied, finally starting to come down from my intense climax.

    "Malik's one lucky guy, huh?" Wyatt laughed, patting my back in the same way he patted his football buddies after scoring a goal.

    "I've never fucked his ass before," I admitted to my brother. "But I definitely will after this."

    As if he could tell we'd been talking about him, Malik returned to my house a couple of minutes later. All four of us gathered in the basement again, eating the cheesecake and smoking the weed my boyfriend brought along. I couldn't wait to tell Malik about everything that had just transpired upstairs, but I decided to wait until tomorrow. After all, it was a long weekend, and there was plenty more sex to be had. And anyway, Malik had another topic of conversation in mind; one that was unfortunately much grimmer than sex.

    "Have you told your brothers about… what we're gonna do?" Malik asked me earnestly, and I knew just what he meant. I immediately got uncomfortable. I didn't want to talk about this right now, but then again, it was never the right time for this.

    "What?" Wyatt asked with a big smile on his face, thinking we're talking about something sexy again.

    "We're gonna go to the police," I finally said to my brothers. "I think… I think I know who killed Malik's grandpa. And… it's someone we know. Someone on this street."​